Chefelf.com Night Life: Reinaldovader - Viewing Profile

1- Exactly, and SW lost exactly in these three cathegories of Oscar .

2- ROTS probably won't get nominations because it's not revolutionary like SW was in 77

3- I love Looney Tunes - but why don't the coyote BUY an roadrunner instead of an ACME product? ( probably this could be"reason 1 to hate Looney Tunes" rsrs)

4 I didn't compare SW with Looney Tunes, I just said that SW , Looney Tunes,
Star Trek , Lord of the rings , the life is not to be taken so seriously.

ex: reasons to hate the life:

1 - Why do we die?
2 - Why has God created the Infeccious bacteria and the lung cancer?
3 - Why has God created Osama Bin Laden & George Bush ?
4 - Why don't we have in our solar system , so many planets with intelligent life , good air to breath , good weather , gravity like in Earth , like SW galaxy do ? - why are we alone in the Universe?
5 - Why doesn't God make the explosions in space with sounds so that SW would be correct?

1 -Why did they leave LEIA to die in the trash compactor? Didn't they wanted her alive ? Why didn't they just turn off the compactor , opened the side door and captured them BEFORE they die ?

2 - If Leia knew the Empire had let the Falcon Milenium scape easily because they were being track why did they go the the rebel base ? They should have gone somewhere else - THE EMPIRE WAS TRACKING THEM AND WOULD OBVIOUSLY FIND THE REBEL BASE IF THEY WENT THERE- I never understood this.

Anyway , I could go on and on . My point is: You just can't go making a list of 90
flaws on EP III to prove it is worst than OT , because the whole SW is full of flaws . There are flaws because SW is for children and teens - It's not to be taken more seriouly than "Looney Tunes" . IT'S JUST FOR FUN , not for deep analisys of 90 points as if SW were some philosophical essay to be studied.

EP I really has one flaw: It's not much fun . EP III is a lot of fun and , c'mom , you can't deny: the story is much more complex than EP IV .

Ep IV is very good , but extremely simple:

Bad guy kidnap the princess _ the good guy , the wizard , the tinman , the lion
( WIzard of Oz?) and the american cowboy rescue her _ and destroy the bad guy's fortress - THE END -
The rest is Special Effects - ( all SW oscars were technical cathegories )

1- Yes, they were inside a giant worm . was tehre central heating or anti -gravitacional system inside the worm?

2- why doesn't the worm itself doesn't freeze ?


3 I KNEW SOME PETULANT WOULD COMPLAIN ABOUT MY ENGLISH , FOR LACK OF ARGUMENTS AGAINST MY POINTS - MAYBE WE COULD TALK IN SPANISH, PORTUGUESE, ITALIAN ... WHICH LANGUAGE DO YOU PREFER ? BUT , PROBABLY YOU DON'T KNOW ANY OTHER LANGUAGE ...

4 - I'M NOT MASTER IN ENGLISH BUT I KNOW I CAN BE UNDERSRTOOD VERY WELL AS LONG AS I UNDERSTAND AMERICANS SPEAKING "PORTU-SPANISH-AMERICAN"

5- Could anybody answer at least these:
Why there wasn't anybody waiting outside the thash compactor to arrest Leia, Luke,etc...? Everybody in Death Star knew they were there and wanted to catch them , and it would be much easier to simply open the door and get them....

6- About EP III , it's the best in my opinion , nobody will change it

No me not joking , me right , you wrong , you no argument
you no explain my critics

I would like to understand the logic on this debate:

1 -Chewbacca scream like Tarzan = PROBLEM
Explosions in space = NO PROBLEM
The Robo from Metropolis , or the Tinman of Oz himself walking around
(C3P0) = NO PROBLEM

2 -An american cowboy in space ( Han ) = NO PROBLEM ,
after all , we also have the president of US destroying superpowerfull
Husseinish Aliens in Independence DAy
Anakin cowboy = PROBLEM

3 - Ship falls in direction of the planet in EP III (gravity law) = PROBLEM
Leia an Han don't freeze nor float inside the asteroid = NO PROBLEM
Destroyer "falls" in direction of Death Star ( no gravity )= NO PROBLEM

4 - SW is just a movie = NO PROBLEM
SW makes an reference to other movies ( Tarzan , 7 Samurais ) = PROBLEM

5 - Luke becomes a jedi in some hours = NO PROBLEM
Anakin decides to let his "bad" side flow to achive more power
( like most of people do when have some power in the hands ) = PROBLEM

6 - No stormkeeper is waiting to arrest our heroes outside the trash compactor
(WHY , my God WHY ???) = NO PROBLEM
Dooku decides to make on spectacle ( for everybody ) out of the execution
= PROBLEM


Could anybody explain the logic of this ?
I think the logic is very TARZAN- LIKE : Old trology = GOOOOD !!!
New trilogy = BAAAD !!!

EP III is not only better then the VERY SIMPLE EP IV , but is also the best of them all . EP III is the heart of SW , the center of the saga , the most exciting and well done of them all - My favourite before was ROTJ.