but then he had obiwans ghost following him around a bit. so there may have been the odd chime in... who knows, the important thing is, he wasn't just some chump that showed up and rocked the world the way jariten is implying.
ROTJ is when things began to fall apart, I mean I'm sure at the end of Empire there were still plans for more movies, thus implying that Luke training would be expanded, but all of the sudden Kurtz left, Lucas got divorced? (not sure if it was at that time or before Empire) I do know Lucas had an adopted baby in ROTJ so he changed his mind (again) and forced the ending probably to have more time for his kids.
One year is the official time between Empire and Jedi, why couldn't Luke spent that year in Degobah, no need to show anything, just put it there in the opening spine. It would have been more logic than Yoda saying in Empire is training is not finished and then in Jedi saying his training was finished without any training in between.
what about that? a OT lover finding faults in the OT, Jariten will like this one
Still, Jedi is a lot (and I do mean a lot) more enjoyable than any of the "other" modern movies.
This post has been edited by Gerhard: 10 May 2006 - 09:48 PM