[SithAvenger]

I think that AOTC is the worst one of the PT. Man, at least the other two were a little entretaining. So whcih one is the worst?

[Despondent]

Well, that's certainly a harder question than "which of the PT was the Best?"

[LiocModnar]

AOTC is the one I can't watch so it gets that dishonour. The only thing worse than the painfully slow love scenes in AOTC is the "I love you like I'm blind" scene from ROTS. Fortunately there were fewer (or shorter or else Palpatine successfully distracted me from glaring at the screen as plot strung along between them) ill-written love scenes in ROTS.

[Revan-47]

yah, AotC is the worst one.

[CowboyCurtis]

Dang that's a hard choice... I want to say AOTC, but it's TPM that started all of this crap right off the bat...

[WalkingCarpet]

I'm plumping for TPM. There are more parts of Clones that I can sit through without vomiting blood.

[CowboyCurtis]

I finally voted to give equal share to them all. TPM started it, AOTC perpetuated it, and ROTS nailed it in. There's no way I can pull just one out to be the worst nor the best of three...

[Otal Nimrodi]

*Enter Fanboy mode* I think this poll is unfair. You don't say what if you like the PT. *Exit fanboy mode*

Honestly, I had to say AotC. I can't remember it, it was that bad.

[ernesttomlinson]

Definitely Attack of the Clones. Episode III merely reaped Episode II's foul harvest. Once Lucas established Annie Skywalker in Episode II as an immature, petulant, thoroughly obnoxious little creep, the fate of the PT was sealed then and there.

A nod to Episode III though for its seemingly endless lightsabre fight scenes and for completing the transformation of Amidala into a vapourish, ineffectual nothing of a character. "Oh, Annie, you're breaking my heart." Almost as bad as Peter Jackson's Return of the King and that's saying a lot.

[SithAvenger]

*Enter Fanboy mode* I think this poll is unfair. You don't say what if you like the PT. *Exit fanboy mode*

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

A great fanboy imitator, you are Otal.

[Otal Nimrodi]

Complimented, I should be.

[Paladin]

I'll vote for AOTC. I loathed that movie to no end, and I don't have any secret that I really, really hate it.

But I've never seen ROTS yet, and I think I might even change my mind about getting it on video... but then again, I've spoke of my movie marathon one too many times to just drop it now. So I think I might go for it after all.

My biggest pain is having to go thorugh three annoying as hell movies in one sitting. After that, I might not even go thorugh the OT well, either. Seeing after all the stuff I've heard over here... and the fact that Anakin is the little arrogent. immature shit living in Darth Vader's suit.

[Mnesymone]

AOTC is a shambles - a really disorganised mess. It edges out.

[Harvey Globetrotter]

Almost as bad as Peter Jackson's Return of the King and that's saying a lot.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You've got to be kidding. What was bad about it?

Oh, and TPM is the worst.

[CptSeaMonkey]

LOL, I agree with ernest. The other thing I'll add is that AOTC was essentially made obsolete by ROTS. AOTC established Anakin as always being messed up, Shmi's death as what made Anakin turn to the Dark Side, and the rocky relationship between Anakin and Obi-wan. Then Lucas pulled his punches and undid all of that in the first 10 minutes of ROTS. So basically, AOTC had no point other than to show how Anakin and Padme ended up together, which turned out horrible and in the end, unnecessary since Padme plays no role in ROTS.

Also, I wasn't going to mention it since there seems to be so many LOTR fans on this forum, but for me as a big fan of the books, The Prequels > Peter Jackon's LOTRs, and that's saying a lot.