[Despondent]

Ten Times as good as Ep 1 and Ep 2 combined!

insert sarcastic reply here. All those I give that review to, do.

[StarWarsIsUs]

I thought you said you were going to give ROTS another chance, Despondent?

[Despondent]

Yes, and I shall. I want to do the four night event with eps 3-6. Can't begin on that till thurs due to other viewing obligations.

Sitting on the fence on Sith, not going to pass judgement until I do give it another chance.

Regardless of what gushers and bashers protest, I stand by my comment of 10X better than Eps 1 and 2 combined.

I did watch part of Ep 2 on the telly last night. Just to see it on the flat-screen, I assure you. Meh, it's more fun to poke holes. It was interesting that 3P0 had feelings toward his maker in Clones, and in Sith they didn't even converse.

[StarWarsIsUs]

yeah. I will make a statement and say that ROTS is better than TPM, AOTC, ESB, and ROTJ. Though, not combined together. It is better than TPM & AOTC combined together x100.

That is interesting. Though, I think that is the way it should have been. I don't think Threepio should have been a creation of Anakin. Their lack of conversing, confirms that we can indeed ignore TPM/AOTC's flaw of 'Master Annie'.

[Veer]

I thought it was good. You guys are all in denial.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

It was ridicolous. The movie only got better only when Anakin became Vader and began killing people. Which is what the entire PT should have been about in the first place...

[Richard]

It was ridicolous. The movie only got better only when Anakin became Vader and began killing people. Which is what the entire PT should have been about in the first place... 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Ha, yes. I could have enjoyed ROTS being the first movie, then another two movies just following Vader flipping out and choking people at the supermarket or whatever.

[StarWarsIsUs]

If ROTS were the first movie, it would have totally taken away the effect of the ending of the movie.

[Richard]

If ROTS were the first movie, it would have totally taken away the effect of the ending of the movie.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Maybe. But this loss would be made up for in the possibly thousands of deaths in the following movies, which I have decided would be called;

Star Wars Episode: 2 'A New Choke'

and

Star Wars Episode: 3 'Return of the Choke-hold'

[Veer]

If ROTS were the first movie, it would have totally taken away the effect of the ending of the movie.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Which was?

[StarWarsIsUs]

Veer, I do not have to explain myself. It was a good ending. You are in denial.

Richard, that is quiet funny.

[Lord Melkor]

SO you guys wanted only to see Darth Vader killing people!?

What a pity, I thought there was a story to tell! Ignorant Vader fanboys!

[Veer]

Veer, I do not have to explain myself. It was a good ending. You are in denial.

A good ending does not a movie make. Ofcourse, the movie had several endings, so which one do you mean?

[Richard]

SO you guys wanted only to see Darth Vader killing people!?

What  a pity, I thought there was a story to tell! Ignorant Vader fanboys!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I also want to see Vader hurting people and also belittling them

Not necessarily even Vader. Anyone will do. Jason would do the job adequately.

[BadKarma]

SO you guys wanted only to see Darth Vader killing people!?

What  a pity, I thought there was a story to tell! Ignorant Vader fanboys!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

There WAS a story to tell.. but it was lost in piss poor scripting and an obsession with CGI. Vader killing people would have been shallow and dull after 6 hours of it... but still a damn sight better than what we had served up.

[Veer]

SO you guys wanted only to see Darth Vader killing people!?

What  a pity, I thought there was a story to tell! Ignorant Vader fanboys!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Umm... we did see Darth vader killing people. In fact in the OT, we had three whole movies of Darth Vader killing people. No story to tell there.