[HK 47]

An obvious poll but I was kind of curious to see how the film would be rated here. Do you think it matches RotJ? Better or worse?

[jariten]

well its much much better, but im going to rate it 5 in a knee jerk reaction to everyone whos going to rate it 1 in a knee jerk reaction to everyone whos going to rate it 5.

[HK 47]

Wouldn't be so sure about that Jariten, I am (as you may know) a rabid basher of the PT and I admit that RotS was surprisingly good. I actually think it matches RotJ pretty evenly.
Edit. Still lightyears away from Eps. 4 and 5 I might add

This post has been edited by HK 47: 22 May 2005 - 07:13 AM

[Lord Melkor]

4,5!

Pure entertainment and joy!

I would say slightly weaker in plot to ESB, but much better visually.

Great film anyway!

[fatuglynerd69]

I would give it 5 compared to other two (PM would get 1 and AOTC would get 3).

Compared to OT - 3.5 or 4

It's not better than ESB or ANH, almost as good as ROTJ or even better. After all it didn't have any gay-ewoks .

All in all I quite enjoyed it.

This post has been edited by fatuglynerd69: 22 May 2005 - 08:41 AM

[StarWarsIsUs]

I rated it a 5. It deserves a 10.

"""I would say slightly weaker in plot to ESB, but much better visually."""

ROTS' plot, is much more developed IMO. I think that ESB is a great movie, but ROTS is so much better.

[Lord Melkor]

I rated it a 5. It deserves a 10.

"""I would say slightly weaker in plot to ESB, but much better visually."""

ROTS' plot, is much more developed IMO. I think that ESB is a great movie, but ROTS is so much better.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Look at this guy! He is praising ROTS more than I am!

What do you think about Palpatine`s look when he fought Mace?!

[StarWarsIsUs]

I thought it was greatly done! At first, I was questionable about how his look was going to change, and scared that Lucas would ruin it. But it gives us the 'horror movie' type feel, when we get to see his face transform, directly from his own force lightning. I LOVED it!

[HK 47]

Look at that! Not a single "1" yet and a relatively high average. That's a first on this forum huh...

[Michel Orla]

Definitely a four. The beginning was too chaotic, Vaders first words and Padme's reason for dying both were bad, but other than that I really got into the movie, and unlike the other two PT I really found myself emotionally involved.