[Chyld]

Well, rather than use the slightly less anonymous method of e-mail, I thought I'd stick my suggestions here, why everyone can have a goosey before they don't get added. For ease of noting, I'll add the criteria Yahtz added too.

First of all: Perry Bible Fellowship = damn fucking incredible! Found it a while before somewhere, much joy.

John and John: Y??NNN*

Red Meat:: NNNNNY

Chopping Block: YNNNNN

Be rest assured, I'll find many, many more before tea time today...

[SimeSublime]

Also hating email, I'll add a small note here.

I was surprised you didn't add Something Positive to you're list. It's been awhile since I've read it, so my ratings may be off, but it should be Y N N Y Y N.

I'm less surprised to not see Elf Only Inn, as Sortelli is on hiatus, but it's still good. N N N Y N N.

This post has been edited by SimeSublime: 15 February 2005 - 09:59 AM

[Yahtzee]

I hate Something Positive. Something Positive is what made me write that webcomic update in the first place. It's cliched up the wazoo.

[Chyld]

Got some more for you...

Sexy Losers (Warning: So not worksafe): N Y N Y N N

Minimalist Stick Figure Theatre: Y N N ? N Y

Toothpaste For Dinner: Y N N N N N

[SimeSublime]

I thought the Grimbles closed shop awhile ago. Have to get back up to date, I guess. And out of curiosity, just what is the annoying cute mascot for Sexy Losers?

[Yahtzee]

There isn't one. Read the list more carefully.

And the Grimbles has stopped, I think. But it's still good.

This post has been edited by Yahtzee: 16 February 2005 - 01:12 AM

[Corasan]

What about Checkerboard Nightmare? NNNYNY. (there are strips from 2000, but according to the author, it really begins here.)

[Eggie]

What about Yahtzee Takes on the World?
I still think it's one of the best...

[Ninja Duck]

I'd recommend Cyanide and Happiness (NNNNNN), and of course, I'd suck at self-promotion if I didn't suggest Afghanistani Annie. (NNN Can't Tell NN)

[SSH]

Achtung Franz is excellent, and even has an AGS-made adventure game

[Chyld]

I'm quite aware this thread/idea is kinda dead, but one of the comics I mentioned decided to pull off an entire fortnight of comics based on the Six Cliches List, only namechecking Yahtz... erm... yesterday. And would you believe it, I got all but namechecked...

When I first came onto the "six webcomic cliches", it was on a forum where someone had linked and reviewed my site. While I fell prey to most of the cliches, this particular one (all women=hot) was graded with a question mark. Apparently, due to my crude stick-rendition of women, it's not possible to tell whether or not my characters are supposed to be "hot or not" (dot com). I mean, come on, can't you tell by their shapely bodies and.. uhhh... eyelashes.. that these ladies are teh s3xx0r?

Well, its not my fault, I can't tell how lumpy stickmen are supposed to be...

This post has been edited by Chyld: 17 March 2005 - 04:10 AM

[Thanatos]

I intentionally delayed linking the list of cliches so that the audience (read as: my girlfriend, since she's the only regular reader..) would be surprised by the content. I did due respect in the end, and never pretended that it was my idea. Sorry that I didn't mention you, Chyld.. I rectified that with a "shout out" on the new comic.

Thanks for the interesting ideas, guys! It's great that someone is thinking about webcomics on a symbolic level.. it makes it almost seem like a REAL art form.

I'm quite aware this thread/idea is kinda dead, but one of the comics I mentioned decided to pull off an entire fortnight of comics based on the Six Cliches List, only namechecking Yahtz... erm... yesterday. And would you believe it, I got all but namechecked...

Well, its not my fault, I can't tell how lumpy stickmen are supposed to be...

[Chyld]

Wahey! Namecheck! Shiny goodness! Thanks! Your comics good stuff, in case I hadn't already made the point.

And it wasn't me complaining about not being mentioned, its just that I'm an attention whore at heart...

[Heccubus]

Wasn't "Alien Loves Predator" one of the ones that I suggested in an email that didn't get added before? You did take my suggestion on "A Softer World", however, so yay I suppose.

[Girdag Fireskull]

Can I add Rob and Elliot (N, N, sort of, Y, N, N). BRILLIANT comic. Also Exterminatus Now (N, N, Y, N, N, N)